| Platinum | The Old North End Restaurant & Deli |
| Gold | Granelli's Pizzeria |
| Silver | Scileppi's |
| Bronze | On a Lark Pizza Co |
| Top Pick | 212 Pizzaco |
| Top Pick | Angie's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Parry's Pizzeria & Taphouse |
| Top Pick | Slice Works |
| Top Pick | Stumpy's Subs & Pizza |